US Refiners Continued - If We're Not Going Back to a 2006-2007 Industry Environment, Then They Don't Look Cheap

In regards to US refiners still being priced for good times, in my view as per EV/Capacity analysis. If you have a bullish near term view on their industry, think we're going back to 2006-2007, then fine. The point I make is that if you think we're going back to a 1999-2002 environment, then US refiners such as VLO, TSO, HOC, and FTO still look a bit overvalued despite their massive declines this year. Original refiner piece here.

I had some useful comments on this US refiner work I did, posted over on Seeking Alpha, and wish to republish comment excerpts here at the Stalwart.

Comment Excerpt: Using complexity adjusted capacity might improve clarity given complex refineries trade at a premium. 

Comment Excerpt: One thing you're missing, is that these companies have a lot of "liquid assets" such as oil and refined oil products. In VLO's most recent 10Q, they listed their inventory as including $4.5 billion of refinery feedstocks and products. In addition, the market value of LIFO inventories exceeded their carrying costs by $7.6 billion. So there's another $12 billion in enterprise value that is not reflected in your numbers, although I'm sure this value is smaller since oil prices have decreased since their 10Q report was issued due to falling oil prices.

Yes, but they always have liquid assets such as these. I compare these companies to their own history. Thus in the past they had additional liquid assets as well. There will be some difference, but will it actually be realized? And might it be enough to overcome their high current valuation vs. their capacity, relative to their own valuation history? Or might this liquid asset value just fall with oil prices/ product prices. I think it is not dependable from an investment standpoint to try to add this value and then depend on it as your investment case.

The key point of the piece, is that we are comparing companies by a single metric, and comparing them to themselves in the past. It gives I think a clear understanding of relative value to their own histories. Once we try to start guessing what their inventory values will be, and what they were expected to be in the past, for each year from 1998 until 2008, we start adding a ton of variables with a lot of room for error. 

There are other assets I have not included in the analysis, which I explain in the piece. Such as pipelines and retail operations. But they had other assets in the past, so to some extent we're comparing like to like. 

The point is simply that if we just value capacity, which is the lions share of the value behind US refiners, and just compare this metric to where they have traded in the past (and in the past they had retail assets, other liquid assets as well, so its pretty much a like to like comparsion), then it seems to me very clear that these haven't bottomed out and are still priced for a pretty strong outlook since their EV/Capacity's are above the highs of many years in the past.

Then the next question then is what your call on the cycle is. If you do indeed believe we are returning to 2006-2007 in the near future, then the refiners might be cheap. But if you think we're going to 1999-2002, or something similar, then probably they are still a bit overvalued.

I also haven't, yet at least, done a complexity adjusted capacity. I explain in the piece why I haven't, though I admit it would be useful. Basically, its based on a lot of estimates, and my goal here is to first keep it simple. If something looks cheap by my pretty austere valuation, then it will be even cheaper once we heap on other harder to value assets and adjust above average facilities, which actually all four of these players have. Note that we would have to adjust their capacity in the past as well, so to some extent it would be a wash. (though upgrades to facilities might help the current valuation a bit)

But if I have to heap on somewhat nebulous asset values, which are perhaps a less dependable value, (such as oil inventories at expected market price for example), if I have to add all this in order to make it cheap, then its probably better staying on the sidelines. It means its not cheap enough.

(Vincent)

Comments

[Idil]

Nice article that told me what i need to know

[shaun noll]

contango is steep so you can use that to guage what kind of envior is likely

[generic valtrex]

Hello Great and very interesting blog about US Refiners Continued - If We're Not Going Back to a 2006-2007 Industry Environment, Then They Don't Look Cheap, I'm doing my graduate work about Industry Environment

[buy viagra]

great post about US Refiners Continued - If We're Not Going Back to a 2006-2007 Industry Environment, Then They Don't Look Cheap thanks!!

[buy viagra]

I think that There will be some difference, but will it actually be realized? And might it be enough to overcome their high current valuation vs. their capacity, relative to their own valuation history? Or might this liquid asset value just fall with oil prices/ product prices

[Air Max]

The Nike Air Max 360 brought the most unpaid possitive attention to Nike in this century. Mens Nike Air Max 360 Shoes soft colour:Unique full-length Air Sole?? unit provides durability, comfort and unsurpassed ride.

[dunks sb]

Applying for my first job, I realized I had to be creative in listing my few qualifications. Asked about additional schooling and training, I answered truthfully that I had spent three years in computer programming classes. I got the job. I had neglected to mention that I took the same course for three years before I passed.

[adjustable bed]

Nice article. I am so impressed by your post. Thank you for sharing.

[castlebaths]

Forever 21 has incredibly stylish/fashionable clothes at a really low price. Winners, or your equivalent is also a great place to shop for hip clothes without the expected price tag.
bvlgari perfume

[jmsharry]

Why was your birth date 'adjusted'? here is an idea, go to the philippine consulate in vancouver and ask your question there.
anaheim weddings

[Christian Louboutin Boots]

Forever 21 has incredibly stylish/fashionable clothes at a really low price.

[Alzheimer's]

Yes, thank you for the good information.

[timberland boots sale]

Either a bit tall, or handsome or rich, but not your short waiter at a local noodle shop.Not a tricycle driver. Hence, the couple emanates "specialness' when it is in public.

[NFL jerseys]

Without conducting a lot of research into extended space missions in low gravity conditions and confined quarters such as on an extended lunar mission, there will be no trips to Mars or anywhere else. Venus is not a plausible landing site, it's much too hot, and the pressure is much too high.

[replica watches]

Dear friends,I am a fanatic watch collection, especially the well-known watches, you also can do, just click on my name!!!!!!!!

[Matchmaking Service]

It doesn't make any sense, we have to prove capable of lowering our consumption before they will do anything about the supply.

[polo ralph lauren]

But there are fruitarians who only eat fruit because fruit is supposed to be eaten to spread the plants seeds. Therefore, they see fruit as the least invasive form of eating.

[swarovski jewelry]

It's been suggested that oil spills from nearby refineries might be causing the kills - crude oil is toxic to fish if they ingest it. But it's still too early to say what's happening in Trinidad. Testing is still on-going.

[Wilson Tennis Racquets]

Gun Smoke things were close to changing over to more variety shows like Sonny and Cher, Carol Burnett, Flip Wilson, Every sunday night there was a disney movie.

[Community retirement]

I agree!

[Babolat badminton Racquets]

I hanged Shaq's replica jeresey and Messi's replica jeresy on the wall for that matter Ii is a really nice decoration but i recommend washing it form time to time.

[J.Crew]

From the perspective of computers though, to do that kind of CG, you need powerful computers. Toy Story for instance was all animated in computer and was in the Terabytes.

[Matchmaking Service]

Not at all! It doesn't matter how you pay for the ticket. You're still taking the person out on a date. What matters is how nice you are to you date.

[Retirement community]

Thanks for the recent comments.

[cheap timberland boots]

Your post is the best. I like it,because I learn a lot of useful from your blog,thanks.