When it comes to Feng Shui for the home, I guess it can't really hurt if someone wants to spend money on what is essentially an interior designer. And when it comes to investing, I can imagine its pretty widely accepted that Feng Shui should not directly apply, even by those who perhaps use Feng Shui for their home.
But here's my question... "Should you trust someone in investment management who even believes in Feng Shui at all?" we could even take it further and include anyone who believes in any sort of lucky numbers or other similar forces. For those with money invested in Asian mutual/hedge funds this is a pretty fair question.
The reason is that the world of investment methodology is a pretty confusing place to be with a good deal of nonsense. One of the greatest challenges is probably not to get caught up using a perspective or tool which is foolhardy. If one person's reason allows for Feng Shui to seem proven, then what is one to expect of them when they are confronted by some sort of bogus stock market indicator being hawked by a financial charlatan? If you believe that some numbers/colors/days are just plain lucky, then what's wrong with believing that the number of eyeballs might justify an internet company's stock price?
I have a feeling that belief in Feng Shui, lucky numbers, and other forces is pretty wide spread amongst investment managers in Asia, based on personal experience. Even the ones managing funds of non-asian houses say, just for the sake of random example, a Fidelity or Legg Mason fund. I'm sure things like Feng Shui aren't being directly applied to the investment process per se, but you have to imagine that if someone's capacity for reason can't discern that Feng Shui is bogus, or at least lets nicely say completely unproven by the world of science, then you would have to wonder what sort of reasoning they bring to the table when confronted by the myriad of investment justifications out there for stocks.
Belief in special forces is pretty widespread in Asia, even amongst otherwise highly educated people.
In Hong Kong and Singapore, it is taken so seriously that corporations consult feng shui experts about business strategy as well as interior design. Disney changed the angle of the main entrance of its Hong Kong theme park after consulting a feng shui expert.
CLSA, a regional brokerage firm, issued a feng shui note to clients predicting that the stock market would rise from May to August and that the dollar would remain weak.
"Be mindful of your speculations, especially in the third quarter," said the note, which CLSA described as "topical," rather than a formal investment advisory.
Raymond Lo, a feng shui master in Hong Kong who does readings for corporations, expects industries linked to earth and metal signs to flourish during the Year of the Rat.
"The rat is a symbol of money to the earth industry," Lo said, adding that "strong water element in the year indicates productivity and strong activity in the metal industries."
Lo suggested that investors put their money into property, mining and gold.
Now I'm sure most investment professionals would say that they simply enjoy the entertainment value of CLSA's Feng Shui piece, but deep down might it actually influence them, even if they cover it with a fundamental-sounding overlay? And again, my argument is more about discerning someone's ability to sift the nonsense from what matters in a stock market. This isn't meant to be some sort of anti-Eastern view. The financial community in general, including the US and Europe, has a whole host of questionable beliefs pretty institutionalized into what is deemed "professional investment management." Things such as market efficiency and using standard deviation of returns to build theories and forecasts (since it doesn't work for non-normal distributions - ie. future stock market returns) are pretty questionable.
I just use Feng Shui since it is more easy to expose the fallacy of belief in things like feng shui, than for someone's belief in a stock market prediction model. Perhaps I am alone here, but its a bit scary that pensions are invested into well regarded mutual fund companies, which then have fund managers whose belief structures are steeped in mysticism. Again, I'm sure this will apply to many major fund management companies. I guess you just need to hope for the best, that somehow mystical beliefs and its related lack of critical thinking stays mentally segregated from the investment management process.